This passage is a prime example of al-Tabari’s methodology. Unlike later compilers who might have omitted "embarrassing" or controversial narrations to protect a specific theological narrative, al-Tabari aimed to preserve all available reports—even those that were later heavily scrutinized or rejected by scholars. Today, while many traditional scholars reject the authenticity of this incident, it remains a subject of intense academic study regarding early Islamic history in al-Tabari’s work or more about his historical methodology
Al-Tabari’s methodology was to record reports without necessarily validating them, leaving the analysis to the reader. This included recording the controversial alongside the accepted, which is why the account appears in his History . Summary of the Event Description Volume/Page Volume VI, Page 111 Subject The "Satanic Verses" Incident Key Narrative Muhammad's confession of uttering false verses. Key Quote "I have fabricated things against God..." Context Reconciliation attempt with Quraysh (Mecca).
)
The reference "al-Tabari, Volume 6, Page 111" is therefore a key that unlocks a complex world of historiography, theology, and polemics.
The inserted lines praised the pagan deities of Mecca: "Have you thought upon al-Lat and al-Uzza, and Manat, the third, the other? These are the exalted gharaniq (high-flying cranes) whose intercession is approved." al tabari volume 6 page 111
Key elements present on this page include:
Al-Tabari's Narrative Formula: [Rawi / Transmitter A] ──> [Rawi B] ──> [Rawi C] ──> [Historical Account] Why did muhammad confess to fabricating words? - Facebook This passage is a prime example of al-Tabari’s methodology
"Then the Messenger of God said, ''" Key Context from Page 111:
The Quraysh polytheists, hearing their goddesses praised, rejoiced and bowed down in worship alongside the Muslims. However, page 111 records the sudden intervention of the Angel Gabriel: ) The reference "al-Tabari, Volume 6, Page 111"